Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: This raises a problem for the naturalist. Why should we trust our minds, matter, neurons, atoms randomly banging around, any more than we should trust the minds of a monkey? And that's really what Darwin was getting at when he raised this problem. And if we can't trust our own reasoning, then how can we trust our own conclusion, our reasoning to the conclusion that naturalism is true? So that's where it may become self defeating.
[00:00:26] Speaker B: ID the Future, a podcast about evolution and intelligent design.
[00:00:33] Speaker C: What makes a human life valuable? Is it our intelligence, our consciousness, our ability to reason? Or does it go beyond our abilities and circumstances to something deeper? Welcome to Idea of the Future. I'm your host, Andrew McDermott. Today I welcome Jacob Vasquez to the podcast. Vasquez is a husband and father of two children. He received his MA in Christian Apologetics from Liberty University and his Master of Science in Biotechnology with a specialization in Bioinformatics informatics from the University of Maryland Global Campus. He is a bioinformatics scientist and that's in the area of cancer research. And he's also the founder and president of Truthful Hope, an online Christian apologetics ministry. And if his voice sounds familiar, it may be because we've shared a few conversations that Jacob has done with ID scientists and scholars on ID the Future. So, Jacob, welcome officially to the podcast.
[00:01:31] Speaker A: Andrew, thank you so much for having me. It's truly an honor. I love all the work you guys do@discovery ID the future. I'm a regular listener. And let me tell you, I didn't tell you this before the recording, but I'm gonna tell you now. You have the perfect, like, radio voice. I don't know if anyone's ever told you that.
[00:01:46] Speaker C: I've heard it a few times. Yeah,
[00:01:48] Speaker A: okay.
[00:01:49] Speaker C: But thank you for the compliment. You know, I got started back in, what was it, 1998.
They gave me the chance to have a radio show all about my homeland of Scotland. This is when I lived in South Texas. So I've been doing this a while and I do love the fact that I have a voice to share.
Well, welcome to the podcast and I must say thank you for sharing some of the conversations you've been having with intelligent design scientists and scholars.
They're a great bunch and you've been having some awesome conversations and drawing out some great insights. So thank you for sharing those with us.
Today we're going to talk about a book you've written called Sacred or Secular the Pro Life Case for Grounding Human Value in the Image of God. And it tackles a familiar Debate, but from a different angle. Instead of simply asking when human life begins, you ask what makes human life valuable in the first place? And that's something we do care about with the intelligent design community, is what does make life valuable, what it does, where did it come from?
And how is it that an evolutionary process cannot account for it? So these are all things we love to explore on id, the future. And the content of your book is going to fit right in. Why did you decide to write this book? And why take this particular approach?
[00:03:13] Speaker A: Yeah, so this was originally my master's thesis at Liberty University, and I knew I was going to write on the issue of abortion. I just didn't know what angle.
But I do remember, and I do remember thinking that there has to be a larger issue involved. And I say that because for decades, the central question in the abortion debate has been what is the unborn? And the assumption there is, if we could show that human beings that it's wrong to kill a human being, and abortion does just that, kills and intentionally kills a human being, then abortion will be wrong.
The assumption is if we could show that, then others would say, okay, it's also wrong. But as I think we've all noticed, culture has been shifting quite radically to a point where that assumption doesn't carry as much weight as it has. And I came across that firsthand when I had Greg Koukl on my podcast. He's the founder of Stand to Reason, a Christian apologetics ministry. And we talked about abortion and. And he said that. He said the most important question in the abortion debate is what is the unborn? Because what it is determines whether. Whether or not it's right to kill it or not or whatever. So I was like, that's great. I clipped it, I posted it. And I was thinking, I'm going to go in the comments and defend the humanity of the unborn, scientifically, philosophically. But Andrew, to my surprise, I was just floored by the amount of comments, especially on TikTok, the younger generation saying, who cares if it's human, let's kill it anyway. Or when I gave the numbers of how many abortions, 66 million legally have happened in the US alone since 1973. I got comments saying, let's increase those numbers. And it's not just the laypeople, it's. Scholars have been saying this on the pro choice side for some time now. So that's when I realized, Andrew, that this is not just merely an issue of what is the unborn, because the sanctity of life at this current time has been so overlooked, if not dismissed entirely, that we have to start, we have to take a step back and ask what makes human beings valuable in the first place? And to do that, you have to address this issue from a worldview perspective.
So that's the angle that I took with the abortion debate. And I'm grateful that JP Moreland wrote the foreword because I took a lot of his work. I know he's friendly with the ID community, took a lot of his work against naturalism and really just applied that to the abortion debate.
[00:05:46] Speaker C: Right. Yeah. I think of my wife and I host a book club for young people.
And one of the books we've done recently is called A Student's Guide to Culture. And it reminds us of the idea that with a worldview, it's kind of like belief glasses you're putting on. It's your way of seeing the world.
And to go back to your illustration there, about being floored by the comments, you know, if you're, if you're sharing, if you're telling somebody, hey, let's not kill this. This individual, but that individual has different glasses on than you. You know, they're not. It's not going to resonate, is it? Well, who cares if it's a human, you know? And so your book goes deeper than that and tries to. To make a different argument. Right, about the value of humans in general. Why are they valuable?
That's what we're going to get into now. You're a bioinformatics scientist working in cancer research, and you begin your book with a brief look at what modern embryology tells us about the beginning of human life. What can biology establish about the unborn? And why do we need to go beyond that to establish this inherent value of life?
[00:06:57] Speaker A: Yeah. So as a scientist, I was really. I say this in the first line of the chapter. I was really tempted to write more on embryology and the science behind it all.
But at the same time, it was such a conflict. I also was disheartened that I even had to write a chapter on it because in my master's thesis, it was only a paragraph or two in the introduction. Mainly because despite being a popular lay argument from pro choicers, like on social media, that the unborn's not a human being. Pro choice philosophers in the scholarly realm do not hold this view because they rightly acknowledge that the scientific consensus is. Is that the unborn are biologically human.
And that's just so well established. But I did present it anyway, just for the lay folks and the arguments that come about. So I'll briefly go over some of those reasons, but then also show the misunderstanding that I think is really at play here. And it's more philosophical. So just first things first, is the human genome, right? We know with modern medical technology, biotechnology, which is what I do for full time, is we could test to see what species is an organism a part of. So we could see which genome that they, that they possess. And we could see that the unborn have the human genome, so therefore they are human beings. But we don't even have to go that far. And in the book I deploy the law of biogenesis, which simply says the offspring you reproduce after your own kind. So I lay out this really simple mathematical equation. Human father plus human mother will always equal human offspring. It's never going to be human father plus human mother equals parasite to then one day be human being, never the case. I do address the parasite objection, but no need to do that here.
I also show that the unborn, from the very beginning, from conception, are living, distinct and whole. They're living in that they're growing. And dead things don't grow. So we know that they're living. They're distinct in that they're not merely mom's DNA or just not merely dad's DNA. It's a distinct DNA at conception, distinct from mom and dad. That's the zygote. And then it's whole because it self directs its own growth. So it's unique from a stem cell or the other cells throughout the body. And I cite a bunch of biologists who really go into detail, exploring really the beauty of, of the zygote in its earliest stages. It's such a beautiful thing to just examine and discover.
But then I also, I like to consider this kind of like a mic drop in a way in the book, in that there was a survey done of about 5,000 biologists asking the question when does human life begin? And 96% of them said that life begins at fertilization.
Now, for some, that might be surprising, but if you open up an embryology textbook, you'll see it right there for most of them, and I quote them in the book as well.
So it just seems overwhelmingly the case that the unborn are biologically human. And pro choice philosophers acknowledge this too, like Peter Singer, he is a hardcore Darwinian evolutionist, openly acknowledges that, but he writes, and I quote him, that the unborn are undeniably human, biologically human. And then David Boonen, another pro choice philosopher, same thing. Amidst the biological Humanity of the unborn.
But this is where it gets, this is where it twists.
They acknowledge the humanity of the unborn, but they make a distinction that's more philosophical. They distinguish between the biological humanity of the unborn and the human person.
So they say, yes, sure, the unborn's a biological human, but it's not a human person with value until consciousness, rationality, viability, whatever it might be.
And I think, Andrew, I think a lot of lay people, especially young folks, I think most know that the unborn are scientifically human. I think they're trying to articulate this philosophical distinction, but they don't know how.
And I think there's still some type of like a scientism involved where they think if I just say that abortion is right or allowed because scientifically the unborn's not a human being, then therefore it has more authority. And I don't want to open the can of worms of philosophy.
I don't even think it would do much to the pro choice view if they just said scientifically it's a human, but philosophically we have to talk more. But I just think they don't really know how to articulate that yet. But that's really what I dive into much further in the book is that philosophical distinction.
[00:11:40] Speaker C: Right? That's helpful. Now in your book you contrast the substance view of personhood with the performance based view and you argue that equal dignity follows from our shared human nature regardless of any differences in ability. Why does that distinction matter when we're talking about the dignity of every human being?
[00:12:00] Speaker A: This is such an important question. And this is why JP Moreland rightly wrote in his foreword that this book is not just another pro life book. And not to say there's anything wrong with pro life books, I cite a bunch of them in the book. They're necessary. But this book that I wrote I think goes beyond the abortion debate. It's certainly about it. But the conclusions drawn impact almost every part of our bioethical framework. Euthanasia, ivf, abortion, certainly capital punishment, you name it. It permeates that because it's worldview based. So when we're looking at pro choice pro life, what we see from the pro choice side is more of a performance based view. And that's really to say you are valuable based on what you can do or what you can't do. So if you have consciousness, you're valuable. If you have a developed brain, you're valuable. If you're not consciousness, you're not, and so forth. But this also impacts your Health status. So if you have down syndrome, you're less valuable than that. Who doesn't have down syndrome? You could see where it gets a little slippery at that point. The substance view on the other end says you're valuable not because of what you can or can't do or your health status. You're valuable because of what you are, a human being. And what I argue later in the book, I add to this conclusion and I say you're valuable because you're a human being. And to be a human being is to be made in the image of God. Now I don't argue that from the start because I already know the God of the gaps objections flying in people's minds. I get there, I reason there. But the secular pro life view will say that that is based on, as you mentioned, a shared rational human nature.
[00:13:44] Speaker C: Okay. Yeah. And when you, when you get right down to the performance based view of human beings, you know, it's so relative. Like anybody could decide differently than someone else just by having a different measure of performance. You could even say that since, you know, our brains are not fully developed as young people until, until our 20s, well, maybe we can dispense with the youngers, you know, I mean, you could just go to town on performance based.
So it's very important that we can agree on a substance based view of human beings or at least find clarity in that area.
Now let's touch on the three fundamental features of humanity that you argue. Naturalism has a difficulty explaining. You've got consciousness, rationality and human dignity. Why do you call these recalcitrant facts? That's a fancy term. And what makes them so difficult to explain within a materialistic worldview?
[00:14:40] Speaker A: Yeah, no, it's a great question. So I got that fancy term recalcitrant from JP Moreland and also these three facts from him as well. As I mentioned, this was my thesis and I was really trying to dig up my unique angle and I was wrestling with my professor at the time. I had this view in mind. It just wasn't as tightly knit as it is now that it's published and whatnot. But he had given me this book by J.P. moreland titled the Recalcitrant Imago Dei.
And I have it back here. It's a phenomenal read, super technical. So I had to read it like three or four times. I highlighted the whole thing. I tore the pages up and I just, I was floored by how this could be applied to the abortion debate directly because pro choicers and secular pro lifers to either dismiss or defend the personhood of the unborn, seem to assume certain morally relevant characteristics such as consciousness, rationality and human dignity, but don't argue for them from their worldview. And I found that to be really concerning, especially if we're going to use these characteristics to determine if we can intentionally kill an innocent human being. So what I do, and I think it's chapter three and two and three, is I examine the pro choice view and the secular pro life view. And by secular pro life I mean not invoking God. So both pro choice and secular pro life coming from a naturalistic worldview.
And I see what are they assuming? And I point out that they're assuming these three characteristics. So just really briefly, David Boonen is a pro choice philosopher. He says that the unborn do not have the right to life until they have conscious desires. I break that down further, but just on the face of it, that assumes consciousness. But I have not seen him right on justifying consciousness from a naturalistic worldview.
Sentience. Peter Singer is a Darwinian evolutionist and he in part grounds personhood in sentience and also having mental, you know, having memories over time. But sentience is self awareness and self awareness is also consciousness. So it just assumes the existence of consciousness. But I have not seen Peter Singer write on this. I have not seen him write on the philosophy of mind viability. Also, you're a valuable human being when you're viable. You could survive on your own, but that assumes human value. What is valuable about a viable human being versus a non viable human being?
[00:17:11] Speaker C: And
[00:17:11] Speaker A: then lastly, brain development, a developed brain infers personhood and value rather than a non developed brain. But why is that the case? And why is value associated with a developed brain? But even more so, I think there's an applied assumption here, an implicit assumption that a developed brain can then do something.
And I'm assuming that doing something is rationalizing or reasoning. As Mary Ann Warren said in her paper, she's a pro choice philosopher.
But that assumes rationality. So again, you have to explain that on the naturalistic worldview. And my argument is they haven't. And then I further argue, which we'll probably get into here, that it can't be explained on the naturalistic worldview, which is why it's a recalcitrant fact.
[00:17:58] Speaker C: Okay, makes sense. And you know, with consciousness we know that the brain is involved in our mental lives, but does explaining the physical workings of the brain adequately explain our subjective experience?
Let's just dwell with that for a second. What do you See as the fundamental problem for a purely materialistic account of consciousness.
[00:18:20] Speaker A: Yeah, and this is where I lean heavily on JP Moreland, right, because he has done so much great work in this arena. But I, I give three reasons why I think conscious consciousness is such a problem for the naturalist. One, it does not possess the characteristics of physical objects. Physical matter possesses spatial location and extension, but mental states like thoughts, simply do not. I mean, if you and I right here think about a pink elephant and our shared friend Michael Egnor, who is a Discovery friend, friend of Discovery Institute, come and open our brains up, he's not going to find a pink elephant anywhere. I think I give a description of a baseball. It's like when we describe a baseball, we could describe it as a white round object, maybe 3 to 4 inches away from the wall. Red laces, weighs x amount x height and width. But with a mental thought you can't do any of that sort. So it doesn't seem like mental thoughts are physical.
So if that's the case, then mental thoughts are not physical. But this begs the question.
Naturalism cannot explain how spatially arranged physical matter can then produce non physical mental thoughts or subjective experience. So how does matter produce non matter? That's really the question.
There's also the problem of intentionality or aboutness. Mental thoughts exhibit this weird aboutness, this subjective experience. It's not merely knowing a fact, but it's knowing what it's like to know that fact. Like my wife is a baker and I know when I walk in that kitchen and I smell her muffins, I know what it's like to be that hungry. And it's great, don't get me wrong, but I know what it's like. But an AI machine does not and will not know what it's like to know certain things. It might know things it might know pattern recognition, it might be able to draw conclusions, but it won't know know what it's like to be married because that's a subjective experience. It certainly won't know what it's like to be married to my wife because it's subjective. So physical states like firing neurons or like I mentioned computer code do not possess this aboutness or intentionality. And then lastly is the mind body contingency. And this is that mental states seem to be correlated with specific physical brain states. Like you have a pain, you have an itch, so they seem to be correlated. But naturalism cannot explain why a particular brain state will result or produces a specific conscious experience.
I mean, how does consciousness, how Does a specific arrangement of matter produce a particular conscious experience?
And then I ask how complex does it have to be? If it's a brute fact, like if it's one less neuron banging around in a specific way, do you still get that same experience?
What about 2 or 5 or 10 less neurons? So it just seems very arbitrary, but also question begging in the same sense.
Now if I could, can I just go over one or two objections that often come up that maybe some listeners might be hearing? Yeah, that would be
[00:21:29] Speaker C: helpful.
[00:21:30] Speaker A: The most common is emergence. And I see this all the time in our comment section claiming that consciousness simply emerges from, from spatially arranged matter in some complex way.
But I don't think this solves anything. I don't think this explains anything. All it does is merely restate the problem. Because my question back to that person is, well, how does a complex arrangement of matter produce consciousness? That's really the question that we're trying to answer.
So I don't think that does the trick. But then also some, like the late Michael Denton would say consciousness is just an illusion. But I think that's just an incoherent statement, at very least self defeating, because consciousness is the disording, is the disortant of consciousness. You have to be conscious to say you're having an illusion. So it just doesn't work either. So I think some of these objections simply don't work. I go into much more detail as to, like panpsychism and, and property dualism and some other explanations out there. But ultimately I just don't think naturalism can explain consciousness. And I'm not alone. Thomas Nagel wrote in his book Mind and Cosmos, consciousness is the most conspicuous obstacle to a comprehensive naturalism that relies only on the resources of physical science. If we take this problem seriously and follow out its implications, it threatens to unravel the entire naturalistic world picture. And I think that's something to really consider as a naturalist.
[00:23:04] Speaker C: Sure, yeah. You can't point to consciousness as a prerequisite for the human person without having an adequate explanation for consciousness. Right, right.
So that's a big problem for the naturalist, for the materialist. Now you also explore an argument associated with C.S. lewis and Alvin Plantinga about the reliability of human reason.
Darwin himself expressed doubts about whether a mind developed from lower animals could be trusted. What's the problem here for Darwinian evolution, do you think? Particularly when natural selection is concerned with survival more than things like truth?
[00:23:40] Speaker A: Yeah, this might be my favorite defeater that I went over really. Because as we both know a lot of naturalists and atheists and Darwinian evolutionists like to really hone in on, on reason and logic. That is like their saving grace when it comes to their worldview. But I'm ask can you even explain reason on your worldview? And I don't think they can.
If Darwinian evolution is true, then all things came about randomly through the blind process of natural selection. And since our minds are included in these all things, then therefore our mind is the random byproduct of the blind process of natural selection. But this raises a problem for the naturalist who why should we trust our minds matter, neurons, atoms randomly banging around any more than we should trust the minds of a monkey? And that's really what Darwin was getting at when he raised this problem.
And if we can't trust our own reasoning, then how can we trust our own conclusion, our reasoning to the conclusion that naturalism is true? So that's where it may become self defeating. Now I wrote an article on the Truthful Hope page in Defense of id and it's an acronym code. It stands for Components, Organization, Design and Epistemology. And I'm not going to lay the whole thing out here, but essentially what I argue is would we trust a laptop if it were scattered across the beach, if all the parts were scattered? So that's your components. And in that I raised the origin of life concern, where did the parts come from?
And then somehow it organized itself together by the wind, the sand, the waves, somehow without breaking the electronics.
And that would be the organization, because there's irreducibly complex parts of a laptop. So my question is how does that unfold?
And then somehow it spits out this message of enter your password. That's a specified complexity. How can it do that naturally without any designer? And then lastly the epistemology. I wish I had a better word for it because it's not too appealing, but it's the best I could come up with
[00:25:48] Speaker C: is
[00:25:48] Speaker A: how can we even understand that message? So my, my, my problem I pose to the naturalist is kind of on two fronts here. One, how can we trust the laptop to function at all if it came about naturally, with no designer? And two, if we were made in the same way, which we, we, we, we were on a naturalistic worldview, how can we trust our own thinking? And we wouldn't.
Now the most common pushback is, as you mentioned, is that reliable reasoning contributes to survival.
To this I would say sometimes, but not always.
First, at this point in the book I reference Alvin Plantica's evolutionary argument against naturalism. E A A N and he shows that unguided Darwinian evolution selects for survival enhancing behavior but not objective truth. And if naturalism and Darwinian evolution are both true, then he shows that the probability that our cognitive faculties produce reliable true beliefs is low.
So then if we believe that naturalism is true as a true belief, we would have little or we would have a small reason to believe that being true. But second, even if we put that aside, I do not think it's the case that discerning truth is necessary for survival. At times I could even say that believing false things is better for survival. I like what Victor Report said. I cite this in the book as well. He has a beautiful illustration.
It's helpful for us to discern that a snake is in front of us, a threat and something that should activate our fight or flight. We could all agree on that.
But wouldn't it be more beneficial for survival to associate everything that even remotely closely resembles a snake as a threat to us so that we fight or flight no matter what? Even let's say a pool noodle?
Yeah, it would be better for survival, but it would also be wrong. But for whatever reason we have this immediate capacity. Even my 3 year old daughter can tell you without me teaching her that a snake is one thing and a pool noodle is another thing. One is a threat and one isn't. That's a true belief that doesn't necessarily contribute to survival. I would say it might even harm it. And then lastly, developing such rational ability does not come cost free. It's very costly during development to garner up these resources for such a rational capacity. So one could even say it's more resource intensive for reproduction which could be harming. So I do not think and I argue a bunch more from free will and from others explaining why rationality is a defeater for for naturalism.
[00:28:33] Speaker C: Yeah, well, let's turn to human dignity for a few moments. If human beings are the unintended products of blind evolutionary processes, what grounds the idea that every human life possesses inherent and equal value?
Why do you think Darwinian naturalism struggles to provide that foundation?
[00:28:52] Speaker A: Yeah, I would like to punt over to some Darwinian evolutionists to answer this question. I'll quote Yuval Noah Harari in his best selling book Sapiens. He said just as people were never created, neither according to the science of biology is there a creator who endows them with anything. There is only a blind evolutionary process devoid of any purpose leading to the birth of individuals. Equally, there are no Such things as rights in biology. And then Peter Singer, the pro choice and pro infanticide advocate who confidently supports Darwinian evolution with his co author Helga Kuss, I believe I'm pronouncing her last name correctly, said that the only possible way to justify human equality and intrinsic unique moral worth in the traditional sense is indeed by the metaphysical grounding of the Judeo Christian doctrine of the imago dei. Now traditional is important because in their book later on, they argue for an alternative view of equal value using different ethical frameworks. But I think this quote says it all in my opinion. But then Michael Ruse says this of morality, of human value. I appreciate that when someone says love thy neighbor as thyself, they think they are referring above and beyond themselves. Nevertheless, such a reference is truly without foundation. Morality is just an aid to survival and reproduction and any deeper meaning is illusory.
So if naturalism is true, then all of these authors are correct. But the problem is that it's not consistent with how we live, nor is it consistent with reality. To hold that every human being possesses equal value, there must be some shared baseline, like a universal factor, kind of like rational human nature that all human beings have. But remember, we just talked about the performance based view of value.
If that's the case, then we're basing value on certain characteristics. The issue is that we vary in those characteristics from person to person. Some are more sentient than others, some are more conscious than others, some are smarter and stronger than others. But surely it'd be ridiculous if we say, oh, because you're smarter, you're more valuable, you're more sentient, you're more valuable. We would never say that. But if you follow this consistently, that's where you end up, unfortunately.
And then also grounding value in these characteristics has serious implications. And I had an interview with Dr. John west of Discovery Institute on this recently and we really talked about this in depth.
But it flies in the face of what we do. For instance, we take care of the sick, we take care of the poor, we spend a lot of resources on keeping people alive with certain debilitating illnesses. And generally we all recognize that as a good thing. But if Darwinian evolution is true and the goal, if there is any goal, is survival of the fittest, then that would be so contrary to what we should be doing. It should be just focusing on the fittest and forgetting about the weak. And this is where eugenics comes into play. Because Darwin had this conundrum in mind. He said, I don't know why we do This, I think he tried explaining it by some human sympathy. Sympathy. But he wrestled with this because it's quite the conundrum. But we all know that we should be taking care of the sick. And if the substance view is correct, the view that we're positioning, then that makes sense because all human beings are valuable despite your health status. What you can or can't do.
Now, if I can do one thing, I just want to comment on one objection that might come up, and that's human flourishing. Because I think this is really important. I spend some time breaking it out. In the book, Sam Harris has said, well, ethics just boil down to human flourishing. Whatever contributes to the flourishing of humans is good. Whatever contributes to suffering is bad. And that comes up all the time. But my question is, why human flourishing? To start, if Darwinian evolution is true, there's nothing special about us. We're no different than the pigs and the monkeys. So why do we care so much about human flourishing? And then also who gets to decide by what means we attain that flourishing? I don't know about you, Andrew, but I'm a huge Marvel fan and I watch the Infinity wars and Endgame movie Avenger movies. And Thanos's goal was to flourish life. And he thought he could do that by eliminating half of the universe.
We all noticed him as the bad guy. We identified him as the guy who was out of touch with reality. But he had in mind human flourishing, or at least flourishing in general. Who's to say he was wrong? Apply it to Hitler, A realistic example. Hitler planned to flourish humanity by getting rid of the Jews. And he thought by exterminating 6 million Jews that would be the way he could do it. Who are we to say he was wrong if he thought he was flourishing humanity? So who gets to be the judge here? And then lastly, this is a difference between moral epistemology and moral ontology.
Sure, we could know, naturalists and theists can know, or idea can know that humans are valuable.
But that's not the question. The question is, why are humans valuable? It goes from how we know epistemology to why the ontology. And that's precisely what I try and hammer down in the book, the ontology of human nature.
[00:34:27] Speaker C: Yeah, and that's, that's the important argument that needs made. I think now some people who accept a naturalistic account of human origins are nevertheless strongly pro life. And you take their argument seriously in the book. Where do you think the secular pro life position succeeds and where does it ultimately fall short?
[00:34:46] Speaker A: Yeah, this is where I probably Got the most pushback from like minded folks because you know, look, secular pro lifers are on our side. They're defending the unborn and I applaud them for that. I'm so grateful for them, Muslim, Catholic, Jew, everyone who I disagree with theologically. If you're on the side of defending the unborn, I am with you to the end.
But I have to ask the question, can you justify the very claims you're raising, even in defense of the unborn? And I noticed that the same problems that the pro choice naturalist has really also applied to the secular pro lifer, the pro lifer who's a naturalist. And I say that because, let's just look at what they say. They say that the unborn are valuable, all human beings are valuable because they share a rational human nature. But what does that assume? It assumes rationality exists and is reliable and it also assumes that that's valuable.
But I'm asking why, And I really would hope that they consider, like I, I've said this, Andrew, a ton of times on interviews that a secular pro lifer will agree 100% with what I say. In the fifth, halfway through the book, first half, the second half, they're going to have to do some wrestling. But I like that because I think that's where we get the most out of our arguments. So I love what they're doing and I do not mean to diminish those secular pro life view at all by pointing that, pointing it out. I don't mean to attack, but I do want to ask the question, can we justify our claims?
[00:36:17] Speaker C: Yeah.
Which is a great question to be asking.
Okay, so we've explored some of the difficulties you see with naturalism. What positive evidence do you see that suggests that consciousness, rationality and human dignity are better explained by an intelligent designer rather than a blind process?
[00:36:37] Speaker A: Yeah, this is, this is really important because to avoid committing God of the gaps. Right. And I have a chapter called Objections and I literally point out the God of the gaps. Because what I'm not doing is I'm not saying naturalism cannot explain these three characteristics, therefore intelligent designer. I'm not saying that. I'm saying naturalism has trouble explaining these characteristics. And an intelligent designer better explains this specifically the Christian view that we're made in God's image, therefore God. That's where I'm going. It's more of an inference to a best explanation. So what I do after pointing out all these inadequacies, I then build a positive case. And for saving time, I'm not going to go through the whole thing. But I will briefly say it. I think it can be presented quite briefly in that if we're made in God's image, if that is true, then we would resemble the image in which we bear. So to understand humanity, we should understand whose image we're made in. And that's more theological. But what we can conclude from that is that we are conscious because we are made in the image of a conscious being.
We are rational because we are made in the image of a rational being.
And when you drill down on the theology enough, you see that we're made in the image of a rational God in order to know him. So the rationality has a purpose. And then lastly, we're intrinsically valuable because we're made in the image of God.
Where value itself stems from it is to be made in the image of the most High. There cannot be any higher. So it's not merely we're unique from other animals because uniqueness does not equal value.
But we're set apart intentionally. That's a whole different ballgame. We're set apart intentionally bearing the image of that which is most valuable. So I think there is a positive case to be made for the image of God for an intelligent designer from personhood. And I call this the imago DEI argument from personhood, or idap. And in other words.
[00:38:47] Speaker C: Okay, yeah, that's, that's really interesting. And you unpack this in the book, to what degree do you get into it complexity wise? Do you go whole hog or do you point to other resources that people might pull out for that?
[00:39:02] Speaker A: I mean, I, you know, I told you before the recording, the thesis was 100 pages. It ended up being 351. So I think as I was writing, I just thought there's going to be so many objections because it's, I mean, look, it's a lot that I'm covering. Consciousness could be its own book and it has been rational human dignity. These are all fields that people specialize in. And I don't have a PhD, nor have I wrote in a whole, you know, book on each topic. But I do try. I mean, I think I have about 400 footnotes, so I try and point people to those as much as possible, but I try and handle the underlying objections like maybe not that the higher level things, but the underlying objections that come about.
And yeah, I mean, I do get pretty theological at some point. So after concluding that naturalism cannot explain these things, then I do punt to, well, are we made in God's image? And Then what I do is I open up the biblical account of what that means and we go into that further. And that's really the tail end of the argument.
[00:40:03] Speaker C: Okay.
Now, we live in a culture that's increasingly shaped by materialistic assumptions about what human beings are and their value.
So what do you hope that readers of your book are going to take away in terms of understanding and valuing human life? If you had to put it in a nutshell,
[00:40:22] Speaker A: yeah, this is a really good question. I actually spilled this out openly in the introduction. And I told this to you pre recording too, is my goal with the book. This might shock some is not to convince someone to be pro life. Obviously, I would love that, but it's not my goal.
My goal also is not to convert someone to Christianity. Again, I'm a Christian. I would love that.
But I don't argue for the resurrection or other points of argument that I think are necessary. Rather, my goal is much more modest. It's to influence people to think differently about abortion. It's not a political issue. It's a matter of life or death. And it's not merely an issue of biology. It's more of a philosophical issue that has to be handled at the worldview. So it goes beyond just the issue of abortion, like I mentioned, euthanasia, ivf, all these other key issues that we're battling in our culture today. It has significant implications.
So it's really more of a modest attempt of just changing the way people think about human nature at large.
[00:41:22] Speaker C: Okay. And in that, I think it's adding to the debate. So thank you for writing it. Now, how can we get a hold of the book?
[00:41:32] Speaker A: Yeah, so it's out now. It released September 18th.
You can find it on Amazon. We have paperback, hardcover, Kindle, and Audible, so all the good stuff there.
And you can find it on our website, too. Truthfulhope.com Sacred or secular? That's our landing page. So it'll just link you out to the Amazon page. And all I ask, if you're a listener and you want to read it and you do get it, if you could leave an honest review, that would be really helpful, just to get the word out. I am not a big name, don't have a massive following, but JP Moreland does. So his name on the COVID certainly does help.
[00:42:10] Speaker C: Yeah. All right. So the book's called Sacred or Secular. And the website is truthfulhope.org and there'll be a landing page. You can access the book there. And it's also for sale on online retailers like Amazon. Barnes and Noble, right?
[00:42:25] Speaker A: Yep. Yeah.
[00:42:26] Speaker C: Okay.
[00:42:26] Speaker A: Should be Barnes and Nobles. I'm not too sure. I know Walmart. It is for sure.
[00:42:30] Speaker C: Okay. All right. But definitely ways to get, get a hold of it.
Well, Jacob, thank you for your time. This has been good to, to unpack this.
It's a very, very important question, and I, I'm grateful that you've put a resource together that's helping to address it. So thank you for coming on the show today.
[00:42:48] Speaker A: Yeah. Thank you so much, Andrew. I really appreciate it.
[00:42:51] Speaker C: Yeah. And we'll probably be hearing from you again at some point as we continue to share interviews that you do. And hey, maybe I'll come on your show and we'll talk. Talk about certain topics that are important to both of us, namely technology and AI.
That's a whole other conversation.
Well, listeners, viewers, if you enjoyed today's content, consider sharing the podcast with a friend and leaving a positive review on Apple podcasts, Spotify, even YouTube. You can post comments there. And that just helps us reach a different audience and reach more people with the arguments for intelligent design. So thank you in advance for your help for ID the future. I'm Andrew McDermott. Thanks for joining us.
[00:43:35] Speaker B: Visit us at idthefuture.com and intelligentdesign.org this program is copyright Discovery Institute and recorded by its center for Science and Culture.